So you hate touchscreen phones because you can break it?

Yes you loved it before you broke it?

Seems to me you hate that you broke your new Android device rather than your device itself.

Yes screens are easily replaceable by any decent tech, however the insurance/cell provider route will be cheaper. They will simply swap out your device for a refurbished unit and transfer your contacts and apps over, no prob.

If you are lucky they wont have any refirb units in stock and if you press the issue they might let go of a new one for you. Make sure you ask.