Just a suggestion here. as i do not know how bad the damage is, the same thing happen to me and the insurance company was going to buy new cladding for me rear bumper, tail gate piece,rt side rear qt panel.i was afaid of the new cladding not matching the old.. my damage was just surface deep,with 1 or 2 inch impressions and deep cuts i pop out the cladding in the rear ,so i had the insurance cover rino spraying all of my claddings, "which is something i wanted to do any way"..and the polyurthane covered all the cuts marks and every thing matches and looks brand new.... may be something you could consider??