I don't have those (I do have the BFG Mud Terrains), but I can tell you that I've heard a lot of good things about the BFG All-Terrains. Recently someone on this board referred to them as "the best truck tires ever made". I have looked at their comparative ratings for tread wear, noise, and on-and-off-road performance on multiple websites and found them to be a superior tire. I believe their construction is also superior. Personally I love my BFG Mud Terrains, but I've done the research and the All Terrains will be my next tires. They will be enough for my off-road needs and give me more performance on the street. The Mud Terrains make the ride a bit sloppy (doesn't feel quite as glued to the road as I'd like) at highway speeds in certain situations, but the All Terrains put more rubber on the pavement and are supposed to be very well-mannered on the road. I will say this for the Mud Terrains though - I believe I was rather aggressive on the twisty KART track at the ERS rally sprints (pics at planetarydomination.com/rally.htm), and the tires were chirping like crazy, but after a few runs on it, they never came unglued. I don't think I should have been able to get away with how I was driving in what I was driving on what I was driving on with anything but a good track tire, but I did. :-)