Hi there!
If I could chime in and say you should leave him negative feedback for sure...there is too much of this going on in Ebay!

If you end up keeping them you need to find a way to seal those exposed edges created by the scratch so the road salts dont start eating away there and into under the chrome finish! I had my original rims replace due to the typical flaking chrome finish that seems to plague these rims!
Best of luck,
Dave