Yeah, like transio said - I don't think either of those will fit over the hubs. If you order them from some place like NTB they'll test fit them for you before you commit. Sometimes they'll make you drop a deposit though.

Personally I think they both look bad@$$. I think they'd both be really hard to keep shiny though. The top ones you could probably get an overall clean faster, but you'll never keep the area around those small bolts clean. The bottom ones would be a pain to clean every time, but they would at least be possible to keep perfectly clean if you're persistant. For those of us that do clean our rims, this is an important consideration.