Anyone else ever had this problem?

Changing my oil for the first time. Piece of cake EXCEPT...

I have three oil filter wrenches here, an adjustable and two cap type. The filter that's on here is a Vavoline. The adjustable is slightly too big to get it off, just spins. The one cap type that fits on the replacement filter I'm going to use won't fit on the vavoline, slightly too big. The other cap type is slightly too small. I'm not sure if they even make a size inbetween. I keep having to walk to the auto parts store cause I already have the oil out of the truck. I've tried wedging a latex glove inside the adjustable but I can't seem to get it to stick enough to turn.

Damn this is a fristrating.

A 15 minute job is turning into all day.

Any tricks?