yeah, that last pic really shows how pathetic it was when it was so light gray. ANd one close up of the front shows the Restore/Refinish peeling off.....man I had a run of bad luck with cladding issues. Now I have all thick black Herculiner along the entire lower part, from bottom of door frame down. So weird cuz it was never chalky, which we see makes cladding go light gray....but mine, just had that "special" look!

....and yes, my Herculiner is BLACK! LOL

....well wait a minute, maybe it's dark charcoal.....oh nevermind!