This appears to be a reboot of the basket many of us purchased several years ago. If it is you want to buy the larger size if you have any aspirations of carrying a full size spare, especially if that spare is oversized vs stock. One new feature I'm pleased to see is the girding underneath the longitudinal beams. The old baskets don't have that support, so if you drag your tire on it while loading it bends down. I like this idea much better.