Man, that's crazy....hope it doesn't happen again...

I like Yokos too. just put the Yoko Geos A/T-S on my GX last week...pretty decent, moderately aggressive A/T tire.

The Kuhmo is ranked 3rd and the Geo M/T 7th in TireRack's survey for that category (Off-Road Max Terrain). I wouldn't even put the General Grabber 2 in this same category as the others. "Marlin" had them and I recall he commented he kept piercing the sidewalls when on trails.

Here's the TireRack survey, may want to read the comments, see what owners say about all the ones you're interested in. Those really gnarly mud tires can get pretty loud on the highway after a while.
http://www.tirerack.com/tires/survey....jsp?type=ORMT