Alright brake light switch should be fine. My lights work even when the shifter does not.
UPDATE!
It works. My issue was a sticky solenoid. It would not full actuate, or if it did it would take its time and slowly do so. I cleaned it up as there have been some drinks and debris spilled in that area, then lubed it up with WD 40 and so far so good. I am going to keep the cover off for the next couple days to monitor it.
Thanks again for the advice and the video.