I used to think that way, then I got more into wheeling, tore open a new AT2 on the sidewall, threw away 200 bucks. I decided after the PITA of changing a tire on the trail/mud/slop etc... I might as well get something that will eliminate the problem. The remaining tires did not go to waste, they are now on my wife's 2010 F150 I got her for Vday. "Waste not want not" (at least that is how I convinced her that I needed 4 new tires)