scott- my sincere apologizes for further TJ'ing your thread....
i completely agree with riff raff, that for a serious offroader, the kilby plates are the best of the best, i am sure that you could beat the living *&$# out of em and bash as hard as you possibly could and they would hold up to the abuse... and really $800 for a serious belly pan like that is just about the right price to be honest... its just not for some of us VX'ers because even though we like to fantasize that we offroad, we really dont spend that much time offroading, we just like to talk a big game 
and as far as an alternative, i had a friend/shop build me a set of plates for $250... they are definately not as strong as the kilby plates, and i would not say that they would last for 10 years if i went to moab 5 times a year.... but they work well for my small adventures here in colorado and once a year to moab.... although mine are not plates, they are skid bars-
they have 5@1 1/2 steel bars protecting from the radiator to the first x-member (1st axle)
then the have 4@1 1/2 steel bars protecting from the 1st axle to the x-case cross member...
so basically they protect- engine oil pan, tranny oil pans, front half of x-case, steering...
oh, and i have the trooper x-case skid to keep the x-case in one piece...
i know there was a picture from this year in moab where you can see the full skid bars.... but they were taken by someone else and i cant remember who, so i cant find em (maybe cece and gill?)
"Do Not Seek Praise. Seek Criticism."
"If You Can't Solve A Problem, It's Because You're Playing By The Rules."
"The Perosn Who Doesn't Make Mistakes Is Unlikely To Make Anything."
-Paul Arden