Shopping around the last few years, I've always found Mercury insurance and 21st century (AIG now) to be the cheapest. This year, tried farmers with renters insurance to get group insurance and it is cheaper (for both) than everyone else.
You can get quotes for 21st century and progressive online in 15 minutes. Put the VX down as 'Pleasure' while the other car as daily driver to school/work. Also using a higher deductable helps (I have $1000 for comprehensive).